How do I respond to a reviewer?

How do I respond to a reviewer?

Provide a “yes” or “no” answer whenever possible. When the reviewer is correct, state so in your response. Your goal is to show the reviewer that you took their comments seriously, and you should quickly convey what you did in response to their critique.

How do you write a peer review comment?


  • Justify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.
  • Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.
  • Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.
  • Be professional and respectful.
  • Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!

How do you respond to a journal editor?

Read, calm down, reflect, wait a day or two before responding, get author input. Always thank the editor and reviewers • Reviewers are asking questions so that the answers can help improve the manuscript. Authors must also add changes to the manuscript.

How do I become a reviewer for a Journal email?

Contact editors directly: Email the managing editor of journals that interest you, describe your area of expertise and ask to be added to their reviewer database. You can also do this directly on Publons. Register for a free account and volunteer to review for any journal that partners with us.

Do reviewers get paid?

It is true that most reviewers (actually, nearly all) do not get paid. It is said to be an altruistic act that would be considered to be prestigious. But, there is a journal that functions differently. It is called Collabra, you could read the news about it here.

How are peer reviews helpful?

Peer review allows students to clarify their own ideas as they explain them to classmates and as they formulate questions about their classmates’ writing. This is helpful to writers at all skill levels, in all classes, and at all stages of the writing process.

What is the purpose of peer review?

Within the scientific community, peer review has become an essential component of the academic writing process. It helps ensure that papers published in scientific journals answer meaningful research questions and draw accurate conclusions based on professionally executed experimentation.

How does peer review help students?

Peer assessment or peer review provides a structured learning process for students to critique and provide feedback to each other on their work. It helps students develop lifelong skills in assessing and providing feedback to others, and also equips them with skills to self-assess and improve their own work.

Who can conduct peer review?

2 Answers. Who can peer-review articles? Anyone competent enough to be asked in the first place. For conferences (e.g., in engineering or computer science), peer-review is conducted by a Programme Committee.

How do I become a peer reviewer ICAI?

A panel of reviewers will be maintained by the Peer Review Board, satisfying the qualification requirements laid down in the Statement, i.e., an individual should be a member of the Institute; possess atleast 10 years experience of audit (for allotment of reviews of practice units falling under Stage III of peer review …

What is peer audit?

A peer review is a periodic external review of a firm’s quality control system in accounting and auditing and is also known as the AICPA’s practice monitoring program. This process strengthens a firm’s quality control and encourages firms to improve processes and to correct any flaws in their system.

Are compilations subject to peer review?

Interpretation — Yes. For firms enrolled in the program, compilations for management’s use only would fall within the scope of peer review.

What role does the aicpa have in setting standards in the industry?

The AICPA develops standards for audits of private companies and other services by CPAs; provides educational guidance materials to its members; develops and grades the Uniform CPA Examination; and monitors and enforces compliance with the profession’s technical and ethical standards.

Which of the following organizations can revoke the right of an individual to practice as a CPA?

The applicable state board of accountancy can revoke the right of an individual to practice as a CPA.

What areas of advanced knowledge are tested on the CGMA exam?

Responses are entirely open-ended and are graded on the four knowledge areas of the CGMA Competency Framework: Technical, People, Leadership, and Business.

Which of the following is an element of quality control for a CPA firm?

The quality control policies and procedures applicable to a firm’s accounting and auditing practice should encompass the following elements: Independence, Integrity, and Objectivity. Personnel Management. Acceptance and Continuance of Clients and Engagements.

Which audit firms are subject to inspection by Pcaob staff?

Audit firms that are subject to inspections by the PCAOB staff include: All audit firms. Audit firms that are registered with the SEC. Audit firms that are registered with the PCAOB.

Do public accounting firms get audited?

Public accounting firms prepare, maintain and/or audit (that is, review and certify) their clients’ financial statements and records. These firms also assist clients in calculating taxes and submitting tax returns. The principal career paths in public accounting tend to require a CPA license.

How frequently does the Pcaob inspect registered accounting firms that audit 100 or more issuers?

three years

What is Pcaob inspection?

A PCAOB inspection is designed to assess the firm’s compliance with PCAOB standards and rules, and other applicable regulatory and professional requirements in the firm’s system of quality control and in the portions of audits selected for review. A PCAOB inspection results in an inspection report.